Practice Management Member Conversations

 View Only
Expand all | Collapse all

One Canonical Drive Instead of Folders?

  • 1.  One Canonical Drive Instead of Folders?

    Posted 09-07-2025 10:26 PM

    In my practice, I've been testing an AI-native system that eliminates folders and file trees altogether. Instead, everything lives in one canonical drive that's tagged and retrievable by meaning.

    The idea is simple: no matter where a drawing, submittal, or record originated, you can surface it instantly - without hunting through nested directories. Over time, the system builds a cross-project memory that makes old knowledge easier to reuse.

    Has anyone else tried or seen approaches like this in architectural practice?



    ------------------------------
    Christopher Bailow
    Principal, Bailow Architects / Bailow.ai
    Boston, MA

    ------------------------------
    AIAU live course - Zurich’s inspiring cooperative housing - Dec 8, 12pm ET, Earn 1 LU HSW


  • 2.  RE: One Canonical Drive Instead of Folders?

    Posted 09-08-2025 08:42 PM
    Chris,
    Keep us posted on how this works out.
    Ed



    AIAU live course - Zurich’s inspiring cooperative housing - Dec 8, 12pm ET, Earn 1 LU HSW


  • 3.  RE: One Canonical Drive Instead of Folders?

    Posted 09-10-2025 10:09 AM

    Thanks, Edmond, will do! The real test will be when it starts building cross project memory so old details and specs resurface automatically. I'll share back once we see that in action.



    ------------------------------
    Christopher Bailow
    Bailow.ai
    Holliston MA
    ------------------------------

    AIAU live course - Zurich’s inspiring cooperative housing - Dec 8, 12pm ET, Earn 1 LU HSW


  • 4.  RE: One Canonical Drive Instead of Folders?

    Posted 09-16-2025 01:49 PM
    Interesting approach 



    AIAU live course - Zurich’s inspiring cooperative housing - Dec 8, 12pm ET, Earn 1 LU HSW


  • 5.  RE: One Canonical Drive Instead of Folders?

    Posted 09-16-2025 06:07 PM
    Im writing this on my cell phone. Sorry for any typos, if any.

    Try Notion or similar platform as an integrated information, basically data extractions with multiple different filtering, multiple tags and data tables.


    Also try an automation app with a platform intergrating your AIs, communications and cloud server. 

    Already some said Notion is outdated and moving on different platforms but it is great for architect firms, particularly for small firms, to manage extensive architectural info, and communications, records, multi related informations. 

    The first step will be setting up a cloud server. 

    I'm using Notion with Make(data and communication), Miro(design meeting and collaboration), google docs and sheets, bluebeam, and good notes and Mopholio on ipad. 




    Hongwoo Alan Joen, AIA
    Principal 


    3810 Wilshire Blvd. Suite 703 
    Los Angeles, CA 90010
    Cell : +1 213.785.4879



    AIAU live course - Zurich’s inspiring cooperative housing - Dec 8, 12pm ET, Earn 1 LU HSW


  • 6.  RE: One Canonical Drive Instead of Folders?

    Posted 09-17-2025 05:58 PM
    Edited by Carlos Cabrera Munoz, Intl. Assoc. AIA 09-17-2025 06:20 PM

    I had mentioned Notion on a previous discussion in TAP. Expanding a bit more on this, I would like to share the following Notion Portals / Templates. 

    I would like to notify that, I do not get any commission for sharing these. I'm only sharing them, to advance our collective professional services even if by a small fraction, and also because I've found the way they are setup, to be really useful.

    As Hongwoo Alan Joen, AIA, says; these can be a good resource for small to mid size offices, who would like to setup a cost effective solution.

    Office Portal (free)
    https://architect-entrepreneur.teachable.com/p/30x40-s-notion-template

    Client Portal (paid)
    https://initiatearchitecture.com/products/notion-client-portal-v2



    ------------------------------

    Carlos E. Cabrera Munoz, Intl. Assoc. AIA 



    AIAU live course - Zurich’s inspiring cooperative housing - Dec 8, 12pm ET, Earn 1 LU HSW


  • 7.  RE: One Canonical Drive Instead of Folders?

    Posted 09-17-2025 11:25 PM
    Thanks for sharing the Notion resources, Carlos - and Hongwoo, your stack example is a great reminder of how resourceful small firms can be when weaving tools together.
     
    I'd offer one distinction that might be useful for the group:
     
    Notion Portals & DIY Stacks
    These lower setup costs and centralize information, but they still rely on folders, tables, and team discipline to stay organized. Knowledge reuse across projects is often limited because information remains siloed.
     
    Canonical Drive Approach
    What I've been testing is a bit different:
     
    No folders, no trees - everything lives in one canonical space.
     
    AI-native retrieval - drawings, submittals, or records are surfaced by meaning and context, not by navigation.
     
    Cross-project memory - the system gets smarter with each project, building a reusable library of firm knowledge.
     
    Less overhead - instead of maintaining portals or templates, organization emerges automatically through tagging and automation.
     
     
    In short: Notion is an app you configure, while the Canonical Drive is an infrastructure you inhabit. The goal isn't just centralization, but freeing up practice leaders and staff from the overhead of organization itself.
     
    Curious if others have experimented with setups along these lines.



    ------------------------------
    Christopher Bailow
    Bailow.ai | Bailow Architects
    Boston, MA
    ------------------------------

    AIAU live course - Zurich’s inspiring cooperative housing - Dec 8, 12pm ET, Earn 1 LU HSW


  • 8.  RE: One Canonical Drive Instead of Folders?

    Posted 09-18-2025 07:36 PM

    Hi Chris,

    I agree with your POV about relying on metadata for content retrieval vs relying on memory to traverse an organized structure. How can I get my hands on this "canonical drive"?



    ------------------------------
    Ashish Agrawal Assoc. AIA
    RARA Designz
    Chantilly VA
    ------------------------------

    AIAU live course - Zurich’s inspiring cooperative housing - Dec 8, 12pm ET, Earn 1 LU HSW


  • 9.  RE: One Canonical Drive Instead of Folders?

    Posted 09-18-2025 08:54 PM

    When I talk about the Canonical Drive, I don't mean a branded product - it's the idea of one continuous space where everything in a practice lives, structured and retrievable by meaning instead of folders.

    In my own work I've been building toward it. I've built Jellyfish GPT (built on GPT-5), which can already take batches of files and turn them into structured briefs, risks, and decisions - that's publicly available now. Alongside it, I've been running a prototype memory spine that powers the Canonical Drive.

    For everyday work, that means I can clean and structure files before major design sessions - like the archived files I had and used for a pre-design demo I just ran of Jellyfish- so all the material is tagged and retrievable. Internally I'm also testing a more robust version built in Firebase Studio that expands the Canonical Drive toward automatically organizing whole archives, not just new work (think google drive, dropbox, local). Happy to share the demo video links.



    ------------------------------
    Christopher Bailow
    Bailow.ai
    Holliston MA
    ------------------------------

    AIAU live course - Zurich’s inspiring cooperative housing - Dec 8, 12pm ET, Earn 1 LU HSW


  • 10.  RE: One Canonical Drive Instead of Folders?

    Posted 09-10-2025 09:27 AM

    Interesting idea. What happens when you eventually migrate or upgrade to a new system? Is the tag data exportable?

    Nancy Hadley, Director, Archives & Records, The American Institute of Architects



    ------------------------------
    Nancy Hadley Assoc. AIA
    The American Institute of Architects
    Washington DC
    ------------------------------

    AIAU live course - Zurich’s inspiring cooperative housing - Dec 8, 12pm ET, Earn 1 LU HSW


  • 11.  RE: One Canonical Drive Instead of Folders?

    Posted 09-10-2025 10:06 AM

    Hi Nancy, thanks for raising that it's a key concern. The short answer is: yes, the information is portable.

    Instead of folders, the system relies on tags, very much like layers in CAD or parameters in a BIM model. Those tags live in a simple, open database alongside the files. If you migrate to another platform, the drawings and PDFs remain in their native formats, and the tag layer can move with them.

    The intent isn't to lock anything into a proprietary setup but to create a flexible layer of organization that makes information instantly retrievable, while ensuring the underlying records stay archival-safe.



    ------------------------------
    Christopher Bailow
    Bailow.ai
    Holliston MA
    ------------------------------

    AIAU live course - Zurich’s inspiring cooperative housing - Dec 8, 12pm ET, Earn 1 LU HSW


  • 12.  RE: One Canonical Drive Instead of Folders?

    Posted 09-30-2025 05:29 PM
    Fascinating idea! I love the ambition and the way it challenges conventional file-system thinking. But I'm also an architect who constantly thinks about "what happens when things break," so here's where my inner skeptic kicks in:
     
    You said the system relies on tags and metadata layered over a canonical drive, and that the underlying files stay in their native formats. That sounds elegant on paper. But I want to dig deeper: how does that architecture affect the security and governance of our firm's intellectual property, contract documents, and client data? How does the model handle information security in practice and what are the mitigations baked into the architecture to protect the firm's sensitive data?

    This does sound like a cool idea though because I also enjoy anything that reduces my time and need to search and organize. Loving the concept and can't wait to see what comes of it!


    ------------------------------
    Michael Perez AIA
    PMKC Leadership Group
    ------------------------------

    AIAU live course - Zurich’s inspiring cooperative housing - Dec 8, 12pm ET, Earn 1 LU HSW


  • 13.  RE: One Canonical Drive Instead of Folders?

    Posted 09-30-2025 07:58 PM
      |   view attached

    Michael - thank you for raising this. You've put your finger on the essential question: it's not just about elegance, it's about what happens when things break and how governance is maintained.

    The Canonical Drive works precisely because it anchors in file hygiene:

    • Anchor in secure storage → All files remain in their native formats inside the firm's canonical drive (Google Drive, SharePoint, or on-premises). That means existing permissions, encryption, and backup policies stay intact.

    • File hygiene as the crux → Before anything enters the canonical space, filenames and structures are cleaned and labeled consistently. This is where governance actually happens. In practice management, the biggest risk isn't hackers - it's us grabbing the wrong "final_v2.pdf" or misplacing a contract. Hygiene reduces that risk at the source.

    • Metadata instead of folders → Retrieval is through project IDs, phase, client, or tags, rather than brittle folder hierarchies. Hygiene ensures the metadata is consistent, which makes retrieval reliable.

    • Auditability and resilience → Every tag and action is logged. If the metadata layer failed, the underlying drive is still intact - nothing is lost, and the index can be rebuilt.

    • Continuity of IP → By flattening into one canonical space, firm history isn't trapped on old servers or retired hard drives. That continuity itself is a safeguard of intellectual property.

    So in short: the Canonical Drive doesn't replace your secure system - it governs it better. The discipline of file hygiene is what turns the architecture from a neat concept into a resilient practice tool.

    I've attached a flowchart overview that shows how this works in practice - from intake and hygiene, through prep and design/compliance, all anchored back to the Canonical Drive with a retrieval loop ("Memoir"). https://claude.ai/public/artifacts/835f0b3d-3835-4ad2-b0f3-9134cd3c1040



    ------------------------------
    Christopher Bailow
    Bailow.ai
    Holliston MA
    ------------------------------

    AIAU live course - Zurich’s inspiring cooperative housing - Dec 8, 12pm ET, Earn 1 LU HSW