Committee on the Environment

 View Only
  • 1.  Reducing Waste

    Posted 23 days ago

    Can someone please invent a tool to convert waste sheet rock, cut-outs, cut-offs, etc to mud on site, so the waste doesn't go to the dump?  A kind of sheetrocker's cuisinart?



    ------------------------------
    Mike Mense FAIA
    Architect, Writer, Planner, Painter
    mmenseArchitect
    mensenyc on Instagram
    Hamilton Heights, NYC and Snohomish WA
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: Reducing Waste

    Posted 23 days ago

    Wouldn't that be wonderful!  I know landscape & paving contractors in California grind up the bits to re-use in their work, but I think they have to peel the paper off first - especially if it's been painted! - and i don't know if there's a machine for that.  Yet. Sounds like a great high school project...



    ------------------------------
    Gail Napell, AIA Emerita, LEED AP BD+C
    Citizen Architect at Large
    San Rafael CA
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: Reducing Waste

    Posted 21 days ago

    You can put this in your specifications today. It's not the onsite tool you're looking for, but a contract requirement in the 01 74 19 CONSTRUCTION WASTE MANAGEMENT AND DISPOSAL section.

    1.3 DEFINITIONS / H. Soil Amendment: Elements added to topsoil to improve its capacity to support plant life. Compost, peat moss, fertilizer, and gypsum are all viable additives. 

    1.4 PERFORMANCE REQUIREMENTS / A.1.x.: Gypsum board: Recycle to closed loop gypsum manufacturing facility or soil amendment.

    Fun fact about this, if your interior waste subcontractor says they are achieving a 75%-80% average diversion rate and they are not doing this, then they are likely not achieving those rates, at least in the commercial world.



    ------------------------------
    Anthony Brower, FAIA, LEED Fellow
    Director of Climate Storytelling
    anthony_brower@theclimatearchitect.com
    Kansas City
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: Reducing Waste

    Posted 21 days ago

    Great reminder of the tools we already have - thank you Anthony!



    ------------------------------
    Gail Napell, AIA Emerita, LEED AP BD+C
    Citizen Architect at Large
    San Rafael CA
    ------------------------------



  • 5.  RE: Reducing Waste

    Posted 20 days ago

    Gail and Anthony

    i don't believe your solution works.  Reliance on big recycling systems has proved woefully unsuccessful in terms of collection, sorting, reuse and documentation.  We need accountable strategies.  Recycling onsite will be accountable.  Certainly the concerns about the paper can be resolved with the capacities of the cuisinart I mentioned earlier.  Consider this a strategy similar to the developing small scale plug and play solar collectors.

    respectfully



    ------------------------------
    Mike Mense FAIA
    Architect, Writer, Planner, Painter
    mmenseArchitect
    mensenyc on Instagram
    Hamilton Heights, NYC and Snohomish WA
    ------------------------------



  • 6.  RE: Reducing Waste

    Posted 16 days ago

    Hi Mike

    Are you saying that we shouldn't include recycling requirements in our specifications?  I do believe in using the tools we already have, and I also believe we can and should go further.

    respectfully



    ------------------------------
    Gail Napell, AIA Emerita, LEED AP BD+C
    Citizen Architect at Large
    San Rafael CA
    ------------------------------



  • 7.  RE: Reducing Waste

    Posted 15 days ago

     No, I am not opposed to any efforts.  But it felt to me as if you were both saying,"don't worry, we've already got this covered."  Too often, it's either or.  And also too often a painless "feel good" move accomplishes little.  The idea that we can't deal with the paper is, I don't know, defense of bad practice?  No need for naysayers, just let the inventors do their work.  Maybe the big players will modify the paper to make onsite recycling possible.  I can hope.

    respectfully



    ------------------------------
    Mike Mense FAIA
    Architect, Writer, Planner, Painter
    mmenseArchitect
    mensenyc on Instagram
    Hamilton Heights, NYC and Snohomish WA
    ------------------------------



  • 8.  RE: Reducing Waste

    Posted 16 days ago

    Composite materials that are not designed to be re-used or recycled are not readily recyclable. Gypsum Board is a good example of this but there are plenty of others, even, ironically, materials that have high recycled content such as composite plastic wood. Painted surfaces are a big problem for this effort as well. Crushing gypsum board and filtering out the paper sounds good but plenty of paint will get into the gypsum and also there are additives in commercial gypsum board products that no one would want in soil amendments. Making design decisions to use materials that can be disassembled and re-purposed is a holistic way to go, but it is limiting aesthetically and commercially challenging. This leaves the professional commercial-industrial waste processors with their market driven technologies as the best option for large scale (not boutique) reclamation. Boutique, holistic design is the best option for demonstrating the aesthetic and technical potential of design for deconstruction.



    ------------------------------
    James Carr AIA
    www.jamescarrarchitect.com
    James Carr, AIA architecture & design
    Brookline MA
    ------------------------------