Hi Robert,
I recently attended a virtual seminar on ATS Seminar entitled: Guide to home elevators. It touched briefly on most types of residential elevators.
There is no better option, only the one that suits your project best. Also, I have found scarce availability of local contractors for this type of product, so I would probably try to rely on the GC and the elevator sub to guide the specification.
I hope this helps.
------------------------------
Ivan Contreras, LEED AP, AIA
Contreras Munoz Architecture, LLC
Miami FL
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 01-08-2026 07:05 PM
From: Robert Mellor, AIA Member Emeritus
Subject: Elevators, Residential- Looking for recomendations from experience
I am a one person firm and haven't had the occassion previously to specify a residential elevator. I would welcome some general thoughts on Hydraulic vs. Cable Drum systems and which have been the most successful from your client's point of view. Speed, noise, reliabity may be considerations.
Also, I would like to see if designers have had success with the Inclinator Company or with Fox Valley Elevators.
thanks in advance for your thoughts.
Brad Mellor
------------------------------
Robert Mellor AIA Member Emeritus
R. Bradley Mellor AIA, LLC
Vienna VA
------------------------------