For me, this has always summed up the dilemma quite well:
"Let us be clear about this, the forms that people used in other civilizations or in other periods of our own country's history were intimately part of the whole structure of their life. There is no method of mechanically reproducing these forms or bringing them back to life; it is a piece of rank materialism to attempt to duplicate some earlier form, because of its delight to the eye, without realizing how empty a form is without the life that once supported it. There is no such thing as a modern colonial house any more than there is such a thing as a modern Tudor house.
"If one seeks to reproduce such a building in our own day, every mark on it will betray the fact that it is a fake, and the harder the architect works to conceal that fact, the more patent the fact will be... The great lesson of history-and this applies to all arts-is that the past cannot be recaptured except in spirit. We cannot live another person's life; we cannot, except in the spirit of the costume ball... Our task is not to imitate the past, but to understand it, so that we may face the opportunity of our own day and deal with them in an equally creative spirit."
Lewis Mumford in The South in Architecture, 1941
In our current era we appear to have many who prefer to be in costume.
While I enjoy an occasional costume ball I choose to not live that way.
-------------------------------------------
Kimble Hobbs AIA
Principal
Hobbs : Design
Longmont CO
-------------------------------------------