Historic Resources Committee

 View Only
  • 1.  SAVE BERTRAND GOLDBERG'S PRENTICE HOSPITAL

    Posted 04-10-2011 02:17 PM
    This message has been cross posted to the following Discussion Forums: Committee on Design and Historic Resources Committee .
    -------------------------------------------

     

     

     

    Dear fellow lovers of historic modern architecture,

    As you may have heard, Bertrand Goldberg's Prentice Women's Hospital in Chicago is endangered. Northwestern University has stated that they intend to tear the building down as soon as they can. This is hindered slightly as there is still a tenant in the lower portion that will not move out until September. Therefore the push is on to try to get the City of Chicago to do something about it.

     

    The effort here locally is being lead by Landmarks Illinois and Preservation Chicago who have both listed it on their most endangered lists. It has also been submitted to the NTHP for listing on their most endangered list too, but that list does not come out for another month or so and we do not know for certain if it will be included.

     

    Below are a number of links to current articles and websites about the issue so you can familiarize yourself with what is going on. The current request is to get as many people as possible to write a letter to Alderman Brendan Reilly who has gotten agreement from Northwestern to hold off for 60 days. Northwestern claims that the building no longer functions for its needs and cannot be adapted to any reasonable use for them. To counter that, Landmarks Illinois has developed a reuse study with three different alternative uses. These have not been formerly unveiled yet (they will be soon), but they do show there are alternatives. This does not mean that Northwestern will relent, but it may get Reilly on our side.

     

     

    WHAT CAN YOU DO?????

    We would like as many people as possible to write a letter to Alderman Reilly telling him to consider local landmark designation and to find a way to save the building. There are a few sample letters on the Landmarks Illinois site you can read. Also please forward this on to anyone you think might be inclined to also support the effort. Showing Reilly that this is a matter of concern that goes beyond the city limits is important. It would be particularly great to get some recognizable names in architecture write a letter. If any of you have such contacts please reach out to them. Also please join the SAVE PRENTICE facebook page at SavePrentice.org where you can continue to follow developments on the issue.

    Alderman Brendan Reilly
    Office of the 42nd Ward
    Suite 510
    325 W. Huron
    Chicago, IL 60654
    ph. (312) 642-4242
    Fax (312) 642-0420
    office@ward42chicago.com

     

     

    Alderman Brendan Reilly
    Office of the 42nd Ward

    Suite 510
    325 W. Huron
    Chicago IL, 60654
    Ph 312.642.4242
    Fax 312.642.0420
    office@ward42chicago.com

    Join the Save Prentice Facebook page at SavePrentice.org.

     

    Landmarks Illinois website entry:

    http://www.landmarks.org/ten_most_2011_prentice_womens_hospital.htm

     

    Preservation Chicago website entry:

    http://www.preservationchicago.org/chicago-seven/2011/heritage/58

     

    Blair Kamin's most recent article:

    http://featuresblogs.chicagotribune.com/theskyline/2011/04/with-reilly-.html

     

    Lynn Becker's blog entry which includes Alderman Reilly's letter to his constituents.

    http://arcchicago.blogspot.com/2011/04/reilly-wins-60-day-delay-on-demolition.html

     

    Thank you for your consideration of this important matter.

    Gunny

     

     

     

    -------------------------------------------
    Thomas "Gunny" Harboe FAIA
    Principle
    Harboe Architects, PC
    Chicago IL
    -------------------------------------------

    AIA26 San Diego June 10-13


  • 2.  RE:SAVE BERTRAND GOLDBERG'S PRENTICE HOSPITAL

    Posted 04-11-2011 12:41 PM
    Gunny,

    Thank you for posting your request for assistance on the HRC and COD discussion forums.

    I hope your posting draws a good response and will encourage others to use the AIA discussion forums to bring AIA members' attention to potential threats to other significant buildings. The discussion forums can be a powerful tool to inform local AIA component members and help them organize an effective response to threats, and make it easier to protect their communities from the adverse effects of needless demolitions.

    One short coming of the discussion groups is that not all members set their preferences to receive messages from each of the Knowledge Communities. However, all the HRC members receive the newsletter each quarter and I welcome an article from you about the hospital. All 6,000+ members receive the e-newsletter. The next issue goes out mid June.

    Also, please contact Harry Hunderman (2011 Chair of the HRC Historic Sites Advocacy Team) to ask about how the HRC Advisory Group can best respond to this threat to Bertrand Goldberg's hospital at Northwestern University. Perhaps the HSAT will be able to draft a letter of support with your help and the help of other members of AIA Chicago, as was done when the SOM buildngs out at Great Lakes Naval Training Center.

    Give me a calll or email me direct if you would like to this discuss futher offline.

    Jamie
    -------------------------------------------
    James Malanaphy AIA, 2006 Chair AIA HRC
    2011 Editor, Preservation Architect
    Saint Paul MN
    651-367-9001
    jjmalanaphy@gmail.com
    -------------------------------------------






    AIA26 San Diego June 10-13