Technology in Architectural Practice

 View Only
  • 1.  project specific web sites

    Posted 10-27-2010 07:46 AM
    A recent discussion on databases got me thinking that this might be a good forum for a question I've posted elsewhere: do you use project specific web sites?  As in, a portal for consultant, clients, and other stakeholders to access project status, upload/download files, and provide feedback.  We have researched many different options, from Google Docs all the way to heavy enterprise applications like Microsoft SharePoint.  There are several that specialize for the A/E/C sector, such as Newforma, Procore, ProjectSolve.  I'm especially interested if anyone has experience with these, but also general attitudes toward the concept of project specific web sites versus other collaboration methods.

    Andy
    -------------------------------------------
    Andrew Craven Assoc. AIA
    Intern
    HBA Architecture & Interior Design, Inc.
    Virginia Beach VA
    -------------------------------------------


  • 2.  RE:project specific web sites

    Posted 10-28-2010 11:29 AM
    I've used SharePoint. Very labor intensive. I briefly became a site administrator instead of a project architect. The firm I was with looked at, I think, Newforma - had a lot of attractive features but they weren't ready to jump in on the cost.

    -------------------------------------------
    Tom Miller
    Project Architect
    Overland Park, Kansas
    -------------------------------------------








  • 3.  RE:project specific web sites

    Posted 10-29-2010 12:45 AM
    We've been playing with Archittrek, www.archittrek.com, on some projects. Only 1 or 2 PAs are actively using it, not me though. Acceptance by clients and such has been lukewarm, though the service appears to have a reasonable pricing scheme. For our project support team, it results in some redundancy of effort, between generating and posting various CA documents. My sense is that most people prefer to have documents and files 'pushed' to them as opposed to having to 'pull' them from a site. One relatively inexpensive scheme I've considered was to continue to pass pdf documents through normal email groups and use something like Dropbox to handle large file transfers. 

    A good part of the issue when using an off-site Web sharing site is how well you can retrieve project files and transactions at a later after the project is over. We also looked at Newforma but with a limited feature set and seemingly astronomical price it was a non-starter.

    YMMV

    -------------------------------------------
    Craig Gaevert AIA
    TLCD Architecture
    Santa Rosa CA
    -------------------------------------------








  • 4.  RE:project specific web sites

    Posted 10-29-2010 07:38 AM
    We settled on using SharePoint and its been working, but after a year left us wondering if there was something better.  SharePoint requires a lot of customization, and like Thomas mentioned, I became a site admin for weeks until we got it running.  I think clients like the interface and we get to market to them everytime they use it.  And IT likes it because its secure.  On the other hand, its failed us at key moments when we've relied on it for a presentation or such.  Its a big hammer for our needs -- we had been using FTP.  But as business grew and clients got more sophisticated, there became a desire to have something more than an FTP site.

    We too thought Newforma was highly priced, and it only offered a few extras beyond SharePoint.  We're still looking at it, but will probably stick with Microsoft in the end.

    Andy

    -------------------------------------------
    Andrew Craven Assoc. AIA
    Intern
    HBA Architecture & Interior Design, Inc.
    Virginia Beach VA
    -------------------------------------------








  • 5.  RE:project specific web sites

    Posted 10-29-2010 10:08 AM
    I have been working with BaseCamp from 37Signals for my one person firm. It is easy to use for my clients and is an affordable way for me to keep key files available from anywhere.

    It is worth a look.

    -------------------------------------------
    Paul Adams AIA
    Principal
    Earth And Sky Architecture
    Denver CO
    -------------------------------------------








  • 6.  RE:project specific web sites

    Posted 10-29-2010 10:57 AM
    I'm currently using a combination of Sharepoint, Buzzsaw, and a corporate web site for file and information sharing.  None of these is as intuitive and easy as I would like.  I used Newforma Project Center in my previous position and found it to be a very helpful tool to organize and keep track of virtually everything.  It requires just a bit of discipline to file documents properly, but it keeps track of emails, assignments, attachments, CAD files, and all construction administration tasks and documents, including transmittals.  I wish I were using it now.

    -------------------------------------------
    Stephen Gibson AIA
    Gibson A+S
    architecture and sustainability
    Bainbridge Island WA
    -------------------------------------------








  • 7.  RE:project specific web sites

    Posted 10-29-2010 01:21 PM
    As a comment and word of encouragement, our firm has been using Newforma for over a year. We continue to explore this platform and learn new elements which are helping us to become more effective. Newforma folks have been very helpful in helping us to costomize the platform to fit our needs. The Info Exchange module replaces the old FTP site and provides greater ability to maintain or self-maintain but really helps to keep files and correspondence in order. Biggest asset is file retreival; locating an email or other document by key words.
    Check it out more deeply.
    Good luck.

    -------------------------------------------
    Patrick Magill AIA
    Associate Principal
    BOKA Powell, LLC
    Dallas TX
    -------------------------------------------








  • 8.  RE:project specific web sites

    Posted 10-30-2010 11:28 AM

    The following came to me as a message. I've deleted the author's name as I'm unsure whether he intended to be known or not, but I think it was intended as a post to this discussion. In any case, here you go:

    We use Newforma here - great for sharing information with consultants - especialy when you get into large file sizes - does not clog up email.  Also good for posting drawing sets.  And unlike an FTP, keeps a job specific record of what you sent, to whom, and even who downloaded the content (and when they downloaded it).  great for when someone swears they "never got the file".

    On the flip side, I am not sure anyone is really using all it can do - most are using it as a depository, but a few of us have tried the RFI's and submittals, but in my opinion this is still the domain of the contractor,a nd they use their own software to keep track of those.  It was a good tool for tracking submittals and transmittals.

    It is also good for emails - especially when you are trying to find an email - it has a number of ways to search (job specific).  What used to take hours during a dispute to find something now takes a few minutes.  Literally.


    -------------------------------------------
    Tom Miller
    Project Architect
    Overland Park, Kansas
    -------------------------------------------








  • 9.  RE:project specific web sites

    Posted 11-12-2010 12:19 AM
    The concept of a "project web site" has evolved significantly since the first "project extranets" in the mid 1990s.  Today there is a new class of technology called Integrated Project Collaboration (IPC) software that consists of web-based applications designed for shared use by entire project teams.  IPC software is a great fit in today's era of Integrated Project Delivery, and it takes the traditional "project web site" to a new level of functionality and integration with the entire team through use of cloud computing technology.

    I maintain a blog that discusses this in more detail, www.integratedprojectcollaboration.com.  I also recently presented an AIA continuing education webinar that had over 500 design and construction professionals registered, which is a good sign of the growing interest in this topic and this new class of technology.

    Several of the companies mentioned previously in this discussion have nice products, but they are not web-based nor do they meet the criteria for integrated project team use.  For example, Newforma is a database application that is installed on local servers in your office.  It is a great tool for organizing your firm's internal documents and information, but it does not equally benefit the other project team members.  A number of firms are using tools such as Newforma for their internal information while also using IPC software for external collaboration with the entire integrated project team.

    Finally, my company, Submittal Exchange, is one of the leading providers of IPC software.  We've been in business for over seven years, we have over 20,000 users utilizing our web-based applications for design, construction, and LEED management, and we have a large and dedicated team of professionals on our staff who spend their time assisting design and construction firms across North America.  You can learn more at www.submittalexchange.com.


    -------------------------------------------
    Matthew Ostanik AIA
    President
    Submittal Exchange
    Des Moines IA
    -------------------------------------------