Committee on Design

 View Only
  • 1.  Record Houses

    Posted 04-27-2011 09:23 AM

    Yes, the Record is a place to talk about the future and direction of design and little about functionality. We used to have ENR for that. Some aspects of practice and tech concerns are addressed in Architect, which would do better if it defined itself as a practice
    journal and let Record be Progressive.

    My concern is that in the 10 yers since I left teaching the Record has become more like A schools of old. Is it not possible to speak of the vernacular in less dismissive tones? The Fountainhead was after all "only a movie."


    -------------------------------------------
    John Dugger AIA
    Principal Architect
    J S Dugger, AIA & Associates
    Gloucester MA
    -------------------------------------------


  • 2.  RE:Record Houses

    Posted 04-27-2011 10:49 AM


    Let me start by apologizing to everyone for the somewhat flaming vitriol that I included in my original post (now deleted by the mods).  Believe it or not, I am actually a moderator here, and really should know better.  Further, personalizing it only diluted my larger point.  I will soften it and repost.

    Alan - I feel Taliesen should have met code (if there was one).  That is the point. Great architecture should be based on more than art alone. Otherwise it is sculpture.

    David -  I would challenge you to consider that all that is not modern is not just quaint and cozy.  Consider the myriad of historic and vernacular based archetypes still developing forward around the world.

    Gary - Modern Architecture is not on trial in my argument, or certainly isn't indeed to be.  I love modern architecture.  In my N.O. presentation I will use Morphosois's Crawford house and Falling Water as examples of modern genius that (to me) seem to respond beautifully to vernacular, history, and culture.  I love all architecture, and dislike all poorly done architecture, irrespective of the style... again, "style blind." I do find that modern architects get way too protective of their ground. Read my post again, the point is to judge content and architectural process over style. Peace!