Housing and Community Development

 View Only
Expand all | Collapse all

Local Home Shows

  • 1.  Local Home Shows

    Posted 06-16-2011 01:57 PM
    A group of residential architects in the San Diego chapter have formed a task force to explore ways to increase  awareness of the value we can bring to a residential project.  One of the ideas we are considering is to staff a booth at one of the local home shows and present short seminars throughout the day at the show.  Attendees would have an opportunity to spend some time talking with an architect about their project at no charge.  We're also talking with the local ASID and ASLA chapters to create a 'Expert Row' at the show. 

    We're wondering if any of you have had success with this approach or anything similar.  Were there specific seminar topics that seemed to be well received?  How was the booth designed?  What collateral materials were used?  Any feedback would be appreciated.  Obviously we'd like to come away from this with some clients, but at a minimum we'd be happy to just increase the awareness of who we are (AIA Architects), what we do, and the value that we can bring to the project. 

    -------------------------------------------
    Kent Prater AIA
    President
    Prater Architects, Inc.
    San Diego CA
    -------------------------------------------
    AIA26 San Diego June 10-13


  • 2.  RE:Local Home Shows

    Posted 06-17-2011 07:39 AM
    We did a Peanuts booth w/ Ask an Architect for 5 cents at our local Spring Show. Was very well received.

    -------------------------------------------
    Craig Isaac AIA
    Architect
    Craig W. Isaac Architecture
    Charlotte NC
    -------------------------------------------






    AIA26 San Diego June 10-13


  • 3.  RE:Local Home Shows

    Posted 06-17-2011 11:04 AM

    In Indianapolis we had a booth space where local Residential Architects took turns at the booth to engage with the public, answer questions about working with an Architect, promoting Architects as well as themselves.  A number of people had follow ups and obtained jobs as well.  We distributed handouts that included a listing of the participating firms and how to work with an architect (each firm provided $200 to the cost), we had a video produced with project images and messages that we displayed on monitors, as well as residential books to engage the attendees.  The handouts included the National AIA "You and Your Architect", and their top ten questions list that are on the website.

    Next year we have also discussed the possibility of "Peanuts" booth, but we will do more than 5 cents.  We are working with the Home Show promoters to be more engaged during the promotion of the event.  We discovered that most people at the Home Show are looking for product information and didn't want to stop for long periods of time to listen to a presentation.  

    I would recommend that you contact Seattle's AIA Chapter.  They have been very involved with the local home show and the Residential Architectural market.  They have a very strong CRAN (Custom Residential Architects Network) committee that has numerous community outreach programs. 

    I also would invite you to become a AIA CRAN member.  We have obtained our own Knowledge Community (KC) designation, we used to be a subcommittee of Housing, and represent all Residential Architects who provide services for single family clients.  www.aiacran.org 

    -------------------------------------------
    Mark Demerly AIA
    AIA CRAN Chair
    Demerly Architects
    Indianapolis IN
    -------------------------------------------



    AIA26 San Diego June 10-13


  • 4.  RE:Local Home Shows

    Posted 06-17-2011 08:42 AM

    Mr. Prater,

                I deleted the following from, "Measuring Design Excellence" because I thought I was getting off the track. Your question made me think about it again. It's not what you had in mind, but it may help in your discussions. 

     

               ... Form and appearance have leap-frogged function as a priority in the minds of some because functional control has been ceded to, or challenged by, others. The warm and fuzzy world of artistic opinion, however, will be a dead end until accompanied by a foundation of functional knowledge that convinces the public we can make an excellent contribution to their daily quality of life.

     

    Plans and Sections

     

                Floor plans have been associated with function, but they are only a piece of the leadership puzzle and their logic often receives inadequate explanation. They look like a puzzle to the uninformed and cannot be adequately explained without sections. This further complicates public explanation. Excellence, however, will never be defined without an adequate explanation of the logic represented.

     

    Systems

     

                System choice is a critical leadership decision but calculation of engineering detail is taught. Appropriate system decisions, however, are one pillar of excellent design that is easily explained when the knowledge is available.

     

    Budget

     

                Value is a critical concern but we have difficulty estimating cost much less equating our decisions to value, especially when they come in over budget. Change orders add to the problem. I always felt specifications, bidding and contracts were the easiest explanations of value. An architect specifies what is expected and the owner pays the lowest bid for the quality defined. Specifications, contracts and project observation ensure he gets what he pays for and the bid spread is often greater than the architect's fees. Design excellence is free when the owner could easily have gone to the highest bidder without you.

     

    Change Orders

     

                Change orders are a fact of life that should be budgeted without embarrassment. If the owner were producing a car for public consumption he would spend billions on mock-ups and tests. The cost of a full scale, full function building mock-up on vacant land would be a comparable effort. This is obviously unreasonable without mass production. Perfect drawings without mock-ups and tests, however, are also an unreasonable expectation and its time to stop feeling guilty. Change orders are often less that 10% of the total project cost and can be budgeted. Given the complexity involved, this is an A in my grade book.

     

    Additional Owner Costs

     

                A budget often fails to address total owner costs that are beyond the scope of construction cost forecasts. I'm not proposing that they be predicted; but that they be itemized as potential expenses to alert a first time owner in particular, and to avoid later surprise. At one time I made a spreadsheet to help owners predict the total scope involved. I'll try to find it in my files for later publication.

     

    -------------------------------------------
    Walter Hosack
    Author
    Walter M. Hosack
    Dublin OH
    -------------------------------------------






    AIA26 San Diego June 10-13


  • 5.  RE:Local Home Shows

    Posted 06-17-2011 09:47 AM

    We did Ask an Architect at  a local AIA event held in a historic urban neighborhood. Not too much walk-in crowd so it was hard to judge. My partner has shared a booth with a GC and his model was on TV ( should have put the ocmpany logo on the model's roof!) It was slighlty successful with only 1 true project of all the leads. Most customers were interested in small remodeling , or thougth they could buy plans there, or thought they could do much of the work themselves and build at $50 / ft. But overall both events raised awareness of what our profession really does contribute . Good Luck! Check the AIA national for backup, brochured etc. and even the local architecture college to participate and bring fun visuals.
    -------------------------------------------
    Kristine Young AIA
    Gould Evans Associates, LLC
    Tampa FL
    -------------------------------------------






    AIA26 San Diego June 10-13


  • 6.  RE:Local Home Shows

    Posted 06-17-2011 12:27 PM

    I have had a booth a few times.  Charlotte's Southern Spring Show twice with CORA and private resort show. Generally I found it a waist of time and money. Staffing a booth for 10 hours a day for 1 to 5 days is a real drain on ones practice. The general public walking a booth line does hire architects this way, AIA or not. The type of person walking booths is not an architect's client. 

    We did promote good will and are out in the public eye.
    Being in the public eye is not what we are known for. The design profession in my opinion tends to hide from the public. The group effort was fun and represented a broad cross section of design professionals, including home designers, AIA architects, RAs, interior designers and landscape architects.

    I will say, I met great people who have a need for good design, appreciate good design. Get lots of free advice chatting with you. Get good referrals to the trade partner groups. However, would rarely hire an architect on price. They are not in the demographic group to afford to plan they way an architect is trained too plan.

    I will say I have was hired for one 30 minute project, one two hour project this way and now have two happy clients. Both clients now know the difference an architect can bring to the table or I should a say what I can bring to the table. The other 5 architects interviewed turned the work down. The work did not fit through their ivory tower's door.  

    I  have not seen the value of AIA architect to a client over a RA. Most residential architects in Charlotte are not AIA. It never comes up in interviews. It may mean something on a base level. I don't know. I am proud to have AIA after my name. I guess I have made piece that residential architecture is not going to get AIA attention as much the  big boys effort to lobby  the government to spend money on design and construction.

    We compete against, designing builders, home designers, architects, cabinet designers, and do it yourself homeowners. I wish the AIA could clearly distinguish the AIA value.  We certainly have had a long enough go at it. I have come to the belief it is not the organization itself as much as the people in the organization. I have not witnessed that an  AIA architect preforms to a higher level than RA or a few home designers.  Charlotte residential RA's  do an excellent job, are well respected and formable competition in an aggressive market place. 
    I believe the AIA should spend more time promoting client satisfaction by using architects than using AIA architects. Like my examples above. No job is too small to be well planned. That is what I sell. looking back over the course of a year, one would be amazed at how many people value a little design help at $150.00 per hour.

    The difference I see between Architects AIA or RA and designers is we sell a relationship that leads to home more than a set of basic shell documents that lead to home. Both business models work by the way. The home design community  is frustrated they can't sell the time architects can or have the relationship we have with our clients. 

    I know several very talented designers who are working hard to do what architects do. They have a hard road climb because their training and  business plan has never been about that. Architects have from the get go. 


     -------------------------------------------
    Donald Duffy AIA
    Don Duffy Architecture
    Charlotte NC
    -------------------------------------------






    AIA26 San Diego June 10-13


  • 7.  RE:Local Home Shows

    Posted 06-17-2011 01:20 PM
      |   view attached

    Kent and other interested residential architects,

    Please consider organizing your residential architects group as a CRAN chapter. CRAN, the Custom Residential Architects Network, was recently conferred status as a full fledged Knowledge Community within the AIA. If you visit the CRAN resources page at AIA Knowledgenet and scoll down a ways, you will find a link to a pdf providing tips on forming a local CRAN committee. Since it is buried in the depths of the site, I have attached it to this post.

    There are already very active CRAN groups in Minneapolis, Cincinnati, Austin TX, Charleston, Indianapolis, and elsewhere and those of us on the CRAN Steering Committee are available to assist you in getting started.

    In addition to home show participation, some of the other awareness programs these groups have developed are home tours, awards programs, and media partnerships. There are also numerous professional development and networking opportunities afforded by the organization of a local CRAN chapter.

    Please join the CRAN KC on Knowledgenet, subscibe to the CRAN Discussion Forum and encourage others in your group to do so.  We also hope you'll consider joining CRAN in Indianpolis on October 14-16 for the 2011 CRAN Symposium. Registration and program details are forthcoming.

    Good luck.

    -------------------------------------------
    Andrew Porth, AIA

    Porth Architects, Ltd.
    Red Lodge, Montana
    -------------------------------------------






    Attachment(s)

    AIA26 San Diego June 10-13


  • 8.  RE:Local Home Shows

    Posted 06-17-2011 02:31 PM

    Kent
    What a great idea.  Our local chapter AIACV has on several occasions had a 'residential architects' night at the Chapter gallery to showcase work on single family projects (new and remodel) and provide a place for the public to meet architects who specialize in working on single family homes.  The events were fairly well attended; it was a unique opportunity for someone to meet a number of architects in a single evening and get a feel for both design approaches and personality - as well as inquire about process and costs.  In my own experience while there was not a direct connection between 'new projects' and 'participation' the events served a very valuable public relations purpose for the AIACV.

    The 'home show' platform is exciting in that it has the potential to 'touch' many more people.  It is consistent with the notion that to connect with people broadly, we should be going to the places where people are (and not necessarily expecting them to come to us).  

    Some of the issues that come to mind that may need some thought include:
     
    How to establish a clear 'professional' distinction from the many booths manned by 'design/build' contractors and drafting services. 

    Would it be open to any AIA member interested in participating or would there be some process in place to select participants? 

    Would exhibits be 'vetted' through some process (to establish some visual / professional consistency) or would each member's display/work stand on it's own and be distinct from the work and approach of other members who participated?      
      
    Please keep us posted!

    -------------------------------------------
    Michael Malinowski AIA
    AIACC VP of Communication and Public Affairs
    Applied Architecture, Inc.
    Sacramento CA
    -------------------------------------------






    AIA26 San Diego June 10-13


  • 9.  RE:Local Home Shows

    Posted 06-17-2011 07:09 PM
    We have numerous basswood 1/4" scale models, which are always a hit at homeshows, whether attenders are interested in building or not. The first year we had a booth, NOTHING, but a year later a $2.5M house client came to us and admitted he just took a brochure, knowing he'd come to us.  We've never missed a year since!

    The best booth is MINIMUM a 10' x 20' booth, filled with awesome and huge photos of your homes and some intricate basswood models of homes.  Grabs everyone's eye.  Don't show plans, ONLY EYECANDY!

    -------------------------------------------
    Philip Stahl AIA
    Stahl Meland Hawley Architects & Builders
    Fargo ND
    -------------------------------------------






    AIA26 San Diego June 10-13


  • 10.  RE:Local Home Shows

    Posted 06-21-2011 10:25 AM
    In 2005, I presented a free seminar on residential design ideas, a sort of "best practices" approach, at the local home and garden show to help build a better design-awareness for attendees, and to give them real good ideas to discuss with their builders (and maybe draw them to the phone to give me a call). I got an attendance prime-time slot with no competition. Five people showed up including two other local architects. The event hall was packed with people browsing the hot tubs, solar panels, floral arrangements, and window displays, and grabbing all the free pens, tote bags, note pads, and candy they could. The community was a vacation and retirement haven, so the residential market was really quite active at the time. The experience left me wondering if anyone really cares about design at all or if the true purpose of home shows are just social events to get people out of their homes and into the restaurants and local shops after the event. I didn't try that again.

    -------------------------------------------
    David Clarke AIA, Senior Architect
    Williams Design Group, Inc.
    President-Elect AIA New Mexico Southern Chapter
    Las Cruces NM


    AIA26 San Diego June 10-13


  • 11.  RE:Local Home Shows

    Posted 06-22-2011 09:45 AM
    I participated in an similar 'expert row' at a home show in Pittsburgh a few years ago. I think the chances of it resulting in work for the architect are slim to none.  The interior designers seemed to do much better!  Firstly, the news paper articles about the show mentioned that the interior designers would be there to answer questions, and people actually brought in photos, drawings, and samples of materials.  The architects were kind of just there without warning, so there were very few questions where people were prepared.  So my advice would be to advertise what types of questions you want people to ask.  ( I felt a bit like Antique Road Show except the people left the ming vase at home...)

    Secondly, DO NOT say that is an "expert" row. I don't know about you, but I am not a true "expert" in anything- there is always someone out there who knows more about a single subject.  The expert sign seemed to attract people like the retired union steam fitter who wanted to quiz us about boiler pressure and pipe wall thickness.  Just advertise it as 'Ask the architect', or something like that.

    Make sure the area is set up with a computer or ipad and a printer.  There were lots of questions that I could have given great advice to if I had access to web pages to show people specific products, or look up the name of the place where they can buy salvaged radiators, etc. 

    Have fun!



    -------------------------------------------
    Suzan Lami AIA
    Lami Grubb Architects, L.P.
    Pittsburgh PA
    -------------------------------------------






    AIA26 San Diego June 10-13


  • 12.  RE:Local Home Shows

    Posted 06-22-2011 10:08 AM
    Architizer is going with "Design Clinic" at the Dwell on Design event tomorrow in Los Angeles:
    http://dod.dwell.com/architect-consultations

    -------------------------------------------
    Kathleen Simpson
    Manager, Knowledge Communities
    The American Institute of Architects
    Washington DC
    -------------------------------------------






    AIA26 San Diego June 10-13