Regional and Urban Design Committee

 View Only

Beyond Eds and Meds: The Case for Cultural Institutions as Civic Anchors

  

By Danielle DiLeo Kim, AIA

Cultural institutions have always helped shape our cities. Today, many are struggling to survive in them. 

This summer, The Philadelphia Inquirer reported that the Philadelphia Museum of Art has a $15M budget deficit. Visitation is down, deferred maintenance is burdensome, spaces are underutilized, and city support has consistently waned.  

A half mile down the city's majestic Benjamin Franklin Parkway, another beloved institution, the Academy of Natural Sciences, affiliated with Drexel University since 2011, is closing its museum doors this month after declining attendance and rising costs eroded its financial footing. The pattern isn't unique to Philadelphia: the Metropolitan Opera in New York has spent nearly a decade managing its own financial strain, cutting its 2026–27 season to its smallest in 60 years. 

When cultural institutions close their doors, cities lose more than a building—they lose a civic place that helped shape how a city understands itself. 

    

Who Gets Called an Anchor 

In a city like New York, Boston, or Philadelphia, anchor institutions can change a neighborhood simply by deciding where to build, whom to hire, or where to spend their money.  

Anchors, like universities and health systems, shape districts and campuses with their buildings, campuses, and infrastructure.  They offer services that educate, heal, entertain, and sustain families and communities. They’re anchors because their impact is long-lasting, over decades, even centuries, and their presence shapes the local and regional identities and economies of the neighborhoods and cities around them. These are the Eds and Meds. 

But a third category exists: the Creds. 

By Creds, I mean the cultural and arts institutions like museums, performing arts venues, libraries, and significant historic sites. These institutions may not employ as many people as a university or hospital, but they tell us who we are. They're often housed in some of a city's most recognizable buildings. They preserve its history, produce its culture, attract visitors, educate generations, and create the experiences that make a place unique. They establish credibility and identity. 

Yet when cities measure economic impact, Eds and Meds routinely get the shout-out, while Creds are treated as a nice-to-have rather than a real economic driver — even as they generate tourism, sustain local jobs, and shape a city's distinct identity. That's a costly mistake. For example, Philadelphia brings in over $3.3 billion from the creative sector.  

Since the pandemic, institutions of every kind have felt the strain. Universities are consolidating campuses as enrollments decline. Hospitals are stretched thin by rising care costs. And museums and performing arts organizations are still working to rebuild the audiences they lost. Underperforming real estate that once felt like a guaranteed asset has become a financial burden, while declining grant and philanthropic funding, rising labor and production costs, aging infrastructure, and shifting donor expectations compound the strain. 

Disruption is forcing every kind of institution to reconsider who it serves, why, and how. The decisions an institution makes about its programs, policies, partnerships, and placemaking impact its relationship with the surrounding city—and its bottom line. 

Physically Anchored Isn't the Same as Civically Anchored 

Here's a distinction that matters: an institution can be physically anchored in a significant location (like along the Ben Franklin Parkway) without being civically anchored. 

A museum can occupy an iconic building while being disconnected from its neighborhood. A university can sit beside a community without meaningfully engaging it. A hospital can employ thousands of people without addressing the conditions that shape its neighbors' health. 

Being a civic anchor means taking a proactive, community-serving role to better the neighborhoods, environments, and communities it's part of, rather than just operating within them. It means hiring and purchasing locally, opening up a classroom or maker space to the surrounding community, or taking programming that normally stays inside the building and bringing it out into the neighborhood. Being a civic anchor requires a reciprocal relationship with place. 

Here's what that can look like in practice: consider the recently completed Obama Presidential Center. It is more than a presidential library documenting the 44th President. It's a campus integrated into historic Jackson Park on Chicago's South Side, designed to serve the broader community with a public library, recreation center, playgrounds, a museum, and extensive public programming. Recent conversations have focused on the library's provocative obelisk form, but the architecture's real value lies in its service to South Side communities. Few institutional buildings or campuses can claim such a mission. 

The Cleveland Museum of Art is another model. Facing a neighborhood surrounded by disinvestment, the museum didn't wait for the city to act. It led a master plan process for the vacant and underused land around it, and that plan became the engine for a much larger redevelopment effort in the neighborhood.  

The question is no longer how an institution can survive on its own. It can’t. The question is what can we build together, with community? Most boards don't raise those issues on their own. They're questions urban designers and architects with institutional clients have to be willing to raise. 

The idea is simple: institutions perform better when communities thrive. 

Our Responsibility as Urban Designers 

Not every museum needs to become a developer. But every institution can strengthen the places that sustain it. This is where urban designers have an opportunity, and I believe, an obligation. 

We're usually brought in to design the campus, the building, the plaza. The more valuable version of our work is helping an institution see itself differently: not as something that occupies a city, but as something that helps build it. 

We were trained to be systems thinkers — to ask why a building belongs where it does, how landscape creates a welcoming and sustainable public realm, and how a campus supports the local economy and social services. It's time to ask the questions institutions rarely ask themselves. 

Boards focus on solvency. Developers focus on return. Planning departments are stretched thin. Our expertise is designing the impact our projects have on the places around them. That's our responsibility. 

I recommend evaluating any institution through five lenses: 

Positioning: how the institution is actually perceived locally, and what needs to shift.[Text Wrapping Break]Partnerships: the relationships that deepen community ties while building institutional relevance and revenue.[Text Wrapping Break]Programming: the activities and experiences that bring value to audiences.[Text Wrapping Break]Placemaking: the physical work of improving a campus and the public realm around it.[Text Wrapping Break]Policies: the internal practices, like hiring and contracting, that have to change to match what an institution says it wants to become. 

An institution that scores well on all five helps shape the city — because someone on the design team refused to let those questions go unasked. 

Making an Impact 

Disruption isn't the end of the story for institutions. It's the opening. Eds, Meds, and Creds are among the most enduring forces in American cities. They shape our economies, our neighborhoods, and our identities. The institutions with the greatest impact understand that their future is anchored to the future of the place around them, and that they can be the shapers of that future. They rarely arrive at that understanding on their own. 

Institutions shape cities. With our help, they can keep doing it for generations to come. 

0 comments
9 views

Permalink